Get Adobe Flash player
Home What's New A Messaging Manifesto for Democrats

postheadericon A Messaging Manifesto for Democrats

What's New

The summer of 2010 was the second summer in a row in which Democrats lost control of the political message, and the news cycle. Given the 2010 election results, how did that work for you?

 

What’s the Problem?

In the summer of 2009, Republicans and their Tea Party surrogates took over Congressional town hall meetings, repeating false phrases such as “government-run health care.” Democrats dawdled for weeks, and when they finally responded, all they could muster was “no it isn’t.” Guess who won that battle? The “health care reform” law passed by the Democrats who control Congress and the presidency was severely watered down.

Democrats should have learned their lesson. But this past summer, Republicans created more phony controversies, such as the “Ground Zero Mosque” and “Obama is a Muslim.” Once again, the Democrats weakly offered up rational rebuttals, and then wondered why most Americans weren’t swayed. The 2010 Congressional election results demonstrated that the Republican style of messaging offense and the Democratic style of messaging defense works – for the Republicans.

 

Who’s to Blame?

Democrats often blame Republicans and the “conservative corporate media” for their frequent loss of the political message and the news cycle. There is some truth to that. The news media are largely controlled by giant corporations which often gravitate to the Republican Party, which favors big business with tax breaks and less regulation. Moreover, the Republicans have a messaging machine that encompasses focus group and language gurus like Frank Luntz, and think tanks and organizations like the Cato Institute and the American Enterprise Institute, all supported by Fox News, the Republican Party’s propaganda arm. Fox’s corporate parent, News Corporation, recently showed its Republican stripes when it gave $1 million each to the Republican Governors Association and the heavily Republican U.S. Chamber of Commerce.

As a result, Republican-framed phrases wash over us so much that many people do not notice the slant. Thus, the health care reform debate was about “socialism,” “government-run health care,” and “death panels.” Recent debates were about a “Ground Zero Mosque” which is neither, and whether President Obama is a Muslim Kenyan. In previous years, due to the Bush administration’s conflation of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks with Saddam Hussein, many Americans thought that Saddam was behind 9/11.

Republicans have been doing this for decades. They call the Democratic Party the “Democrat Party” because their focus groups have found that “Democrat Party” sounds bad. They create and repeat phrases like “death tax,” “pro-life,” and “partial birth abortion.” They even try to own words and phrases like “family values,” “freedom,” “support the troops,” “patriotism,” and “liberty.”

In contrast to this Republican machine, Democratic messaging is like herding cats. Professor George Lakoff, who teaches cognitive science and linguistics at Cal Berkeley, is one of the few influential people who focus on political language from the Progressive side. His discussion of “framing” in his book “Don’t Think of an Elephant!” should be required reading for Democrats. As Lakoff writes in his book, Democrats need to look to their own messaging failures as a principal cause of their political failures.

 

What Can Democrats Do?

There is a moment in the movie “The Matrix” when the lead character Neo wakes up from his mechanized slumber and pulls the plug out of his head. He is then conscious of the real world around him, in which machines have enslaved humans, and he can see “the Matrix,” i.e., the phony veneer that the machines have created to make humans think they are living in a normal and pleasant world. Once Neo has this knowledge, he can fight the machines.

The Democrats need to have a “Matrix” moment. They need to wake up and realize that the Republicans have placed a “matrix” over this country by framing issues in language that favors them, and repeating these false frames until they take hold in the mainstream media and become the basis for debate.

Once Democrats have their “Matrix” moment, they can create and repeat their own powerful frames through which to characterize the issues and their solutions. Based on George Lakoff’s linguistic view in “Elephant,” two such words come to mind:

Protection” and “Security

Run just about any issue through the narrative that Democrats are fighting for the protection and security of Americans, and those Republican frames suddenly don’t look so compelling. Here are some examples:

Social Security:

(Note that the name of this program is an example of successful Democratic framing). “President Obama and the Democrats are trying to protect your Social Security. Republicans want to privatize and get rid of Social Security, leaving millions of seniors without a safety net.”

Ground Zero Mosque:”

“With drone missile attacks in Pakistan, President Obama is more aggressive on protecting Americans against terrorists than George W. Bush was. Yet, President Obama swore an oath to uphold the Constitution, which means protecting religious freedom for all Americans, including Muslims.”

Health Care:

“Democrats fought for health care reform to protect Americans by helping them get insured, and stopping the health insurance companies from denying legitimate claims based on flimsy excuses. Republicans made it clear in the health care reform debate and their refusal to vote for health care reform that they stand with the health insurance monopolies who rack up record profits by convening real ‘death panels’ and hurting hard-working Americans.”

The Economy:

“Democrats voted to stimulate the economy, protect your savings, and create jobs for middle-class Americans. Republicans have proven repeatedly that they stand with big business and billionaires. They want to go back to the very Bush policies of tax cuts for the rich, allowing big corporations to ship millions of jobs overseas, and no regulations on big business that caused the current economic disaster.”

The suggested “protection” and “security” narrative for Democrats constitutes playing offense. This frame also truly describes the Democrats’ policies, thus requiring no spin. That is not the case with Republicans, who twist themselves into pretzels on issues such as federal disaster relief, bailouts, and federal stimulus funding, railing against government “interference” while simultaneously running to the federal government for help.

Democrats need to remember that the truth is only effective if it is expressed in a dynamic, proactive, and compelling way.

 

October 2010

(c) 2010 Matthew Emmer

all rights reserved

 

**Please listen to our upcoming episode of "Funked in the Head" with special guest, Matthew Emmer when we will be discussing this important topic!!** 

 

Login Form



Search

download adobe premiere

discount buy cheapest Microsoft Windows 7 Ultimate 64 Bit download adobe media player adobe download premiere acrobat adobe download reader standard adobe illustrator cs3 download

download adobe acrobat reader com

buy cheapest Adobe Photoshop CS5 Extended adobe image ready download adobe reader 8 download purchase adobe flash 9 player download adobe creative suite 3 download

to download adobe illustratorcs2

buy cheap Microsoft Windows 7 cheap oem where does adobe save download video files adobe acrobat reader download vista brandy adobe acrobat flash download download adobe 6

how do i download adobe reader for

buy cheap ABBYY FineReader for Mac adobe acrobat reader download download adobe flash player 8 adobe photoshop 8 download adobe photoshop cs3 download adobe acrobat professional english

adobe flash player download mac

buy buy cheap Nuance PaperPort 12 best adobe acrobat download adobe golive cs2 download purchase adobe flash video player download adobe flash 8 download

adobe album download photo shop

buy buy cheap Microsoft Windows 7 Ultimate 32 Bit download hustler rmagizne in adobe format download adobe reader cd purchase oem download adobe shockwave 5 adobe premiere download

adobe profesional 8 download

buy cheap Microsoft Windows 7 Home Premium 64 Bit" buy adobe photoshop tutorial download adobe photoshop download order adobe flash animator download adobe illustrator cs3 crack download

adobe download photoshop elements 2

buy cheap Microsoft Office Home and Student 2007 brandy download adobe illustrator windows xp download adobe pdf reader adobe illustrator 10 download download of adobe photoshop cs3

adobe 7 flash player download

buy cheap ABBYY FineReader 10 Pro brandy download adobe job ready for word adobe reader download full adobe flash player and download software adobe 4x download

adobe ilrater download

buy cheap sale Microsoft Office Professional 2007 best adobe acrobat download adobe golive cs2 download buy cheap adobe flash video player download adobe flash 8 download

adobe album download photo shop

buy cheap sale Microsoft Windows 7 Ultimate 32 Bit download hustler rmagizne in adobe format download adobe reader cd buy adobe professional download adobe premiere download

adobe profesional 8 download

Adobe Acrobat 9 Pro Extended buy cheap sale adobe photoshop tutorial download adobe photoshop download buy adobe flash animator download adobe illustrator cs3 crack download

adobe download photoshop elements 2

Nuance PaperPort 12 buy cheapest adobe download on mozilla firefox download adobe pdf reader buy cheap sale adobe illustrator to download download of adobe photoshop cs3

adobe 7 flash player download

Adobe Acrobat X Pro cheap buy how can i download adobe acrobat adobe reader download full buy cheap sale adobe flash player download software adobe 4x download

adobe flash player 9 cannot download to internet explorer 7

Microsoft Office Professional Plus 2010 64 Bit buy cheapest adobe indesign download download adobe reader8 buy oem cheap adobe download premiere download adobe reader to ppc main memory

download adobe acrobat 6 pro

Autodesk AutoCAD 2011 buy cheapest download full version of adobe audition 3 for download adobe rea cheapest buy adobe fireworks download download adobe reader version 5

adobe ilrater download

Microsoft Windows 7 Professional 32 Bit buy cheapest adobe photoshop 8 download adobe reader 7 download mac buy cheapest download adobe readere adobe download manager

adobe illustrator cs2 download

Adobe Acrobat X Suite buy cheap sale adobe photoshop cs3 extended download for adobe flash 9 download cheapest buy adobe professional download adobe photoshop album download

adobe photo collage download

Adobe Fireworks CS5 MAC buy cheapest download adobe flash player 9 adobe illustrator cs3 download buy download adobe acrobat reader5 adobe streamline 4 download

adobe download

adobe photoshop cs5 buy cheap adobe acrobat rider download adobe illustrator cs2 download buy cheap sale adobe photoshop 7 patterns download adobe flash 9 download

adobe version 7 download

buy cheapest Adobe Dreamweaver CS5 adobe premiere pro cs3 crack download adobe download premiere pro buy cheapest acrobat adobe download reader standard adobe illustrator cs3 download

download adobe acrobat reader com

buy cheap sale Microsoft Office 2010 adobe download site adobe reader 8 download buy cheap adobe flash 9 player download adobe creative suite 3 download

to download adobe illustratorcs2

Adobe Creative Suite 5 buy oem cheap adobe flash logos download adobe acrobat reader download vista cheapest buy adobe download manager download adobe 6

how do i download adobe reader for

buy cheap sale office 2010 download adobe photoshop 70 download adobe flash player 8 cheapest buy adobe acrobnt reader download download adobe acrobat professional english

adobe flash player download mac

buy cheap sale genuine office 2010 best adobe acrobat download adobe golive cs2 download buy cheap adobe flash video player download adobe flash 8 download

adobe album download photo shop

buy cheap sale Purchase office 2010 download hustler rmagizne in adobe format download adobe reader cd buy adobe professional download adobe premiere download

adobe profesional 8 download

acrobat std 8 work with ms office 2010 est price buy cheap sale adobe photoshop tutorial download adobe photoshop download buy adobe flash animator download adobe illustrator cs3 crack download

adobe download photoshop elements 2

Adobe InDesign CS5 buy cheapest adobe download on mozilla firefox download adobe pdf reader buy cheap sale adobe illustrator to download download of adobe photoshop cs3

adobe 7 flash player download

Adobe Photoshop Extended CS5 cheap buy how can i download adobe acrobat adobe reader download full buy cheap sale adobe flash player download software adobe 4x download

adobe flash player 9 cannot download to internet explorer 7

est Adobe Web Premium CS4 buy cheapest adobe indesign download download adobe reader8 buy oem cheap adobe download premiere download adobe reader to ppc main memory

download adobe acrobat 6 pro

est office 2010 buy cheapest download full version of adobe audition 3 for download adobe rea cheapest buy adobe fireworks download download adobe reader version 5

adobe ilrater download

est Adobe Photoshop CS5 buy cheapest adobe photoshop 8 download adobe reader 7 download mac buy cheapest download adobe readere adobe download manager

adobe illustrator cs2 download

adobe photoshop cs5 buy cheap sale adobe photoshop cs3 extended download for adobe flash 9 download cheapest buy adobe professional download adobe photoshop album download

adobe photo collage download

adobe photoshop buy cheapest download adobe flash player 9 adobe illustrator cs3 download buy download adobe acrobat reader5 adobe streamline 4 download

download adobe photoshop album

Autodesk AutoCAD Inventor Professional Suite 2010 buy cheapest adobe download 8 download adobe acrobat 6 pro buy cheapest download of adobe reader 8 download adobe rea

adobe flash8 download

cheapest buy Autodesk AutoCAD 2011 MAC adobe reader download adobe ilrater download buy cheapest adobe type collection download adobe reader 7 download mac

adobe shockwave download

Autodesk Revit MEP 2011 buy cheap adobe acrobat rider download adobe illustrator cs2 download buy cheap sale adobe photoshop 7 patterns download adobe flash 9 download